← Back to context

Comment by jeffwass

11 years ago

American North Vs South is cultural, and there's no one clear designation.

Having lived in Maryland for 8 years, and 25 years north of the Mason Dizon line on the Northeast Corridor, and having travelled to all 48 contiguous states and visited the U.S. south extensively, I fully agree with the original posters assessment that it's not quite the south.

You bring up the Mason-Dixon Line, but why not the Civil War, another very clear North/South divide? Most Maryland soldiers fought for the Union during the Civil War. But as you said there are still some state parks named after General Lee.

Cuisine is another cultural aspect. Culinarily there's not much native Maryland cuisine that I'd associate with the south. Maryland is most famous for food associated with the Chesapeake Bay like crabs and seafood soups and stews. You'll find more places serving traditional southern foods like Chicken fried steak and BBQ, more than up North but not nearly as much as further South.

Accent-wise, there is a slight twinge that some native Marglanders have but it is nowhere near the southern accent you'd hear as you go further south into Virginia.

There is no universal "southern" culture the way you're defining it. While Baltimore is certainly nothing like Atlanta, neither is either anything like Tallahassee.

I'm not just making this up. This is the generally agreed upon definition, that "In popular usage, the Mason–Dixon line symbolizes a cultural boundary between the North and the South (Dixie)" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mason%E2%80%93Dixon_line#Symbo...

If you just want a list of which are the southern states: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Southern_United_States

  • You should read your own wiki link, as it clearly disagrees with the absolutes you're trying to define.