Comment by test1235
8 years ago
Your last line is the bit I've never been able to understand. If someone is running from you, do you have any legal argument for killing them?
8 years ago
Your last line is the bit I've never been able to understand. If someone is running from you, do you have any legal argument for killing them?
Never say never, but it would be very rare for a fleeing person to pose immediate threat. Examples would be people running for a gun, running to get help, running to kill someone else, or running for cover.
I think all of those cases are covered by any imminent threat clause, and thus do not need special exemptions. Just like there isn't an exemption that you are not allowed to shoot a retreating person. It simply follows because (with exceptions) retreating people aren't imminent threats.
It gets much harder to argue, but you'd have a case if they were, for example, running back to their car to get weapons. I'm sure you can think of a hundred other scenarios as well.
That isn't normal, though. It's likely that you were already feuding, and so the law will look askance at you for not bringing authorities into it much earlier.
What if they have stolen your property. Do you not have the right to get it back by force? Does the value of the property matter? If so, who gets to decide that in the moment?
If you live in Texas you can use deadly force if "the land or property cannot be protected or recovered by any other means". Source: http://codes.findlaw.com/tx/penal-code/penal-sect-9-42.html
I've read but couldn't find again the story of someone shooting a tief to get back his VHS player and walk free.
The value of the property does not matter. They do not pose a lethal threat and therefor cannot be shot. At least, that's how it should be, I don't know legally.
You have zero right to kill someone for stealing.
In Texas you may make use of your weapon to stop the execution of a crime if you yourself are not also engaged in criminal activity. It's far larger than castle doctrine because it applies anywhere.
I'm not arguing for actually using the law to shoot people: I don't ever want to be in that situation myself, but I'm saying depending on the situation you do in fact have the law on your side.
what if they stole your laptop that contains a new branch you havent pushed to a remote yet.
No jury would convict.