← Back to context Comment by labster 7 years ago We need more judges like him to make the judiciary functional. 14 comments labster Reply dang 7 years ago We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15835430 and marked it off-topic. throwaway613834 7 years ago It's funny... I've only ever seen processes get detached from their parents, not threads. labster 7 years ago It's really too bad that the idea of a useful judiciary is off-topic on HN. schindlabua 7 years ago Ruling the wrong way in tech cases may otherwise have unintended side-effects. throwaway613834 7 years ago Thankfully we don't have to worry about that. Just look at Oracle v. Google -- he considered the entire environment in which the code was written and didn't evaluate the case solely based on the arguments. throwaway613834 7 years ago Indeed. Getting more judges like him at the bench may well be our greatest imperative. thesmallestcat 7 years ago We can only hope that he has read through the applicative rulings. throwaway613834 7 years ago Yeah, contradictory rulings could seriously disrupt the normal order. quickthrower2 7 years ago He will make some fine hypothetical judgements. throwaway613834 7 years ago Judging from the downvotes on your comment, I think some fellow HN'ers have failed to make the correct inference as to its meaning (!)... 1 reply → ben_jones 7 years ago Better then the current system that objectifies the working class. throwaway613834 7 years ago We've come quite a long way though. At least it's not like back in the old days where saying the wrong thing could lead to your head getting detached.
dang 7 years ago We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15835430 and marked it off-topic. throwaway613834 7 years ago It's funny... I've only ever seen processes get detached from their parents, not threads. labster 7 years ago It's really too bad that the idea of a useful judiciary is off-topic on HN.
throwaway613834 7 years ago It's funny... I've only ever seen processes get detached from their parents, not threads.
schindlabua 7 years ago Ruling the wrong way in tech cases may otherwise have unintended side-effects. throwaway613834 7 years ago Thankfully we don't have to worry about that. Just look at Oracle v. Google -- he considered the entire environment in which the code was written and didn't evaluate the case solely based on the arguments.
throwaway613834 7 years ago Thankfully we don't have to worry about that. Just look at Oracle v. Google -- he considered the entire environment in which the code was written and didn't evaluate the case solely based on the arguments.
throwaway613834 7 years ago Indeed. Getting more judges like him at the bench may well be our greatest imperative. thesmallestcat 7 years ago We can only hope that he has read through the applicative rulings. throwaway613834 7 years ago Yeah, contradictory rulings could seriously disrupt the normal order. quickthrower2 7 years ago He will make some fine hypothetical judgements. throwaway613834 7 years ago Judging from the downvotes on your comment, I think some fellow HN'ers have failed to make the correct inference as to its meaning (!)... 1 reply →
thesmallestcat 7 years ago We can only hope that he has read through the applicative rulings. throwaway613834 7 years ago Yeah, contradictory rulings could seriously disrupt the normal order.
quickthrower2 7 years ago He will make some fine hypothetical judgements. throwaway613834 7 years ago Judging from the downvotes on your comment, I think some fellow HN'ers have failed to make the correct inference as to its meaning (!)... 1 reply →
throwaway613834 7 years ago Judging from the downvotes on your comment, I think some fellow HN'ers have failed to make the correct inference as to its meaning (!)... 1 reply →
ben_jones 7 years ago Better then the current system that objectifies the working class. throwaway613834 7 years ago We've come quite a long way though. At least it's not like back in the old days where saying the wrong thing could lead to your head getting detached.
throwaway613834 7 years ago We've come quite a long way though. At least it's not like back in the old days where saying the wrong thing could lead to your head getting detached.
We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15835430 and marked it off-topic.
It's funny... I've only ever seen processes get detached from their parents, not threads.
It's really too bad that the idea of a useful judiciary is off-topic on HN.
Ruling the wrong way in tech cases may otherwise have unintended side-effects.
Thankfully we don't have to worry about that. Just look at Oracle v. Google -- he considered the entire environment in which the code was written and didn't evaluate the case solely based on the arguments.
Indeed. Getting more judges like him at the bench may well be our greatest imperative.
We can only hope that he has read through the applicative rulings.
Yeah, contradictory rulings could seriously disrupt the normal order.
He will make some fine hypothetical judgements.
Judging from the downvotes on your comment, I think some fellow HN'ers have failed to make the correct inference as to its meaning (!)...
1 reply →
Better then the current system that objectifies the working class.
We've come quite a long way though. At least it's not like back in the old days where saying the wrong thing could lead to your head getting detached.