Comment by cmenge

'Side-effect free' means that doing it once, twice or n >= 3 times (with same parameters) yields the same result, i.e. what it returns doesn't depend on any remote state that is altered by the call itself.

However, an idempotent HTTP call is certainly not a pure function which some people seem to be mixing up. Pure functions don't work with I/O.

REST is bit more specific and explicitly requires GET to be nullipotent which really means "effect free" - it just reads and doesn't alter the state on the remote system at all.

Side-effects like log files, rate-limiting, etc. will always exist, but they do belong to a different 'layer', so to speak. That is, these should be unobservable side-effects (also think about minuscule effects on the power grid, the fact that a request might write something to an ARP-cache, etc. - they all happen at different layers, so the quantum world state keeps changing, but that's not what this is about). Whether an X-Request-Count header violates the requirements or not depends on interpretation. From the garage door perspective, I wouldn't care...