← Back to context

Comment by alimi

8 years ago

All your work is in 1 commit and you only have 3 total commits in your repo. I'm skeptical that YOU wrote this program.

I'd happily be proven wrong.

19 comments

alimi

Reply
dang  8 years ago

This comment violates HN's rules. Please assume good faith and don't attack people.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

https://news.ycombinator.com/showhn.html

Consider the ridiculous downside of someone being 12, posting their program to HN, and meeting with this as a first comment. How awful.

  • noobermin  8 years ago

    Going to be honest, when I was 14 and learning to program, I quickly learned how shitty and harsh the internet can be, especially the types that frequented forums.

  • the-great-assyr  8 years ago

    Guys, I think you should ALL calm down and stop playing SJW. He simply stated that he doubts the kid wrote the code. Since when having a doubt is considered BULLYING??? Did he insulted the kid? Did he used a slur against him? No. He expressed his legit and reasonable doubt.

    So please turn on your neurons and stop playing mother hen and SJW ok?

    Being skeptical is a right we all have to take advantage of and since it has been made in a respectful way, there are no reasons why attacking the user in the way you all did.

    This politically correct thing is slipping thru your fingers and out of your control of you REALLY and SERIOUSLY think that expressing a legit doubt is considered an act of bullying. Ponder about that.

  • some_account  8 years ago

    No it's not awful. People will doubt him sometime, and it's better to learn how to deal with that and gain a life skill rather than expecting every person to be sweet and supporting.

    There are some kids who just goes on game chats to mess with others, play loud music, bully them, grief them etc. They are usually around 12 years old to 16 years old. I'm sure these things are not new to this kid.

    Welcome to the planet.

    • shawn  8 years ago

      When I was 12 or so I had an interest in being an artist. I was also playing a game that happened to be looking for art work. Specifically, they wanted some models for new monsters in the game.

      I put together my best attempt and submitted it. The work was subsequently torn to shreds by the people on the board, and rightly so: The "monster" looked like a walking boob, and everyone said that the special attack could be to squirt milk.

      I wish I'd been old enough to laugh it off, since it's quite hilarious, but in reality I just stopped trying to be a 3D artist. Stuff like this can have a big impact at a young age.

    • dang  8 years ago

      People can, and do, make that same harden-the-fuck-up argument to support any kind of violence. And it makes sense, since perpetrators were always first victims. But on HN, in our internetty and admittedly trivial way, we want to break that cycle. So no, you can't rough up a 12-year-old here—or do anything with a high probability of amounting to that.

    • mockingbirdy  8 years ago

      Those "no pain no gain" guys with a negative attitude are simply toxic. I was never doubted even when I started to freelance when I was 16y/o.

      I simply wrote the code. There's not much room to bullshit your way through it.

      I think it's mostly jealous people who see some clean code from a 12y/o (I like the functional programming patterns) and think about their own mediocrity. There's nothing to gain when dealing with those people except cynism. It's almost always better to have an empowering environment. We're not playing Darwin games here and feeling threatened by a 12y/o shows a lack of decency and commitment IMO.

kupiakos  8 years ago

I disagree. I'd say having all of the work in 1 commit makes it more likely to have been created by a young programmer. What impresses me the most, and makes me skeptical, is the good code style. I know at least 3 12 year old programmers who might be able to do this, but none of them have this diligence for style.

The program is short enough and I was enough of a nerd at this age to be interested in doing something like this. I just focused on making poorly-designed computer games instead.

rjvir  8 years ago

Everything being in 1 commit seems perfectly normal for this situation.

He likely wrote the entire thing without Git (because he's the only one working on it), then decided to push it to BitBucket when he wanted to publish it.

felipellrocha  8 years ago

So you're saying it's more likely that this 12-year old would have written this thing if he had split everything nicely into small readable commits?

That makes absolutely no sense