Comment by Veen
6 years ago
You'd have a point if the quote in question was a long prose quotation. It isn't; it's a poem and code formatting is often the only way to get poetry to appear reasonable.
6 years ago
You'd have a point if the quote in question was a long prose quotation. It isn't; it's a poem and code formatting is often the only way to get poetry to appear reasonable.
Code formatting does not get poetry to appear reasonable. That's actually the whole issue being discussed.
On the other hand if you don't like each line spaced as a paragraph, as it would be if you try to keep the line structure I. HN non-code text, you can, on HN, use the same convention used everywhere else that it is impossible, impractical, or undesirable to set poetry while preserving the line structure:
“this is a line of poetry / and this is another line / each separated from the next with / a solidus set with space / on either side.”
The whole issue being discussed is that HN made a terrible design desicion when they implemented quotes and code styling for Mobile.
Poetry is not a particularly common use case on Hacker News, though, and I'm not convinced anybody needs to optimize for it.
HN gobbles up literal new lines without code blocks so either the poem would all run together or have blank lines between each line.