Comment by interfixus

> If you’d like empirical data of your own to back this up, here’s an experiment you can run: find an immigration lawyer and talk them through the process of getting Signal working on their phone. You probably don’t suddenly smell burning toast

Well, currently extricating myself from the Signal mess, I really am expecting my smoke alarm to go off any minute.

On intallation a couple of years back, the Signal app desparately wanted to curate my sms traffic, but forgot to inform me it would be holding my message history hostage. Forgot to inform me it would kill my instance, should I ever have the audacity to try setting up on a second phone unit. Forgot to inform me that yes, there is a desktop client, but it is useless Electron crap. Forgot to inform me it would be livestreaming my usage to everyone on my contact list - when I installed, when I reinstalled or changed devices, or when I mistook an ambigous list-feature for a personal book-keeping thing. The last item didn't happen to me, but to an acquaintance who thus had a somewhat embarrassing list of contact spilled out into the open. Not to mention the whole phone number based ID disaster, and the lack of any web interface. Sorry, but I'm out.

Fully aware of serious concerns about the crypto and the privacy, but for UI, consistently well designed client apps, data export, and lack of nasty surprises, I have seen nothing to rival Telegram. Which may help explain why that seems to be where everyone is heading.