Comment by overgard
7 years ago
Encapsulation is desirable because it limits the possibility space of what can operate on a set of data. Referential transparency is desirable because pure programs are much easier to reason about. If I understand what youre saying, it seems youre saying referential transparency and encapsulation are at odds and encapsulation is more valuable, but I disagree. Hiding state maybe keeps things tidy and enforces that you need to use the API, but its not really the point IMO. The point of encapsulation is managing state mutations. Hiding state is only a small part. You dont need to hide state as much when its immutable because then you don’t need to care what other code is doing with your emitted data structures because it doesn’t effect you.
Encapsulation doesn't necessarily mean hiding state. It means hiding the implementation details of how actions mutate the state. The same action called on a different kind of module instance can end up mutating the instance's internal state in a completely different way. The higher level logic should not be concerned with how a module performs an action.