Comment by lolc
6 years ago
Indeed there is no volume management for RAM. You have to reboot to rebuild the memory layout! RAM is higher in the caching hierarchy and can be rebuilt at smaller cost. You can't resize RAM while keeping data because nobody bothered to introduce volume management for RAM.
Storage is at the bottom of the caching hierarchy where people get inventive to avoid rebuilding. Rebuilding would be really costly there. Hence we use volume management to spare us the cost of rebuilding.
RAM also tends to have uniform performance. Which is not true for disk storage. So while you don't usually want to control data placement in RAM, you very much want to control what data goes on what disk. So the analogy confuses concepts rather than illuminating commonalities.
One of my old co-workers said that one of the most impressive things he's seen in his career was a traveling IBM tech demo in the back of a semi truck where they would physically remove memory, CPUs, and disks from the machine without impacting the live computation being executed apart from making it slower, and then adding those resources back to the machine and watching them get recognized and utilized again.