← Back to context

Comment by danso

6 years ago

Since the NPR is a 3 minute listen without a transcript, here's the ACLU's text/image article: https://www.aclu.org/news/privacy-technology/wrongfully-arre...

And here's a 1st-person account from the arrested man: https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2020/06/24/i-was-wro...

16 comments

danso

Reply
TedDoesntTalk  6 years ago

As soon as I saw it was audio only, i left the site. Why do sites do this? How many people actually stick to the page and listen to that?

  • asveikau  6 years ago

    > How many people actually stick to the page and listen to that?

    I just did. 3 minutes wasn't that bad and I wasn't somewhere where it would be a problem.

    > Why do sites do this?

    NPR is a radio network. I have seen that often they do transcribe their clips. I am not sure what the process they have for that looks like, but it seems this particular clip didn't get transcribed.

    Edit: looks like they do have a transcription mentioned elsewhere in the thread. So seems like some kind of UI fail.

  • danso  6 years ago

    NPR does transcribe (many, most?) its audio stories, but usually there's a delay of a day or so – the published timestamp for this story is 5:06AM (ET) today.

    edit: looks like there's a text version of the article. I'm assuming this is a CMS issue: there's an audio story and a "print story", but the former hadn't been linked to the latter: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23628790

    • dhosek  6 years ago

      They transcribe all their stories. Back before the web was widespread, you could call or write NPR and have them mail a transcript to you.

  • 013a  6 years ago

    Well, if anyone were going to do it, you'd think no one would be surprised about it being the "National Public Radio"

    • dvtrn  6 years ago

      Accessibility still matters, or should still matter even if you’re a radio station, but probably especially if you’re a news radio station.

      5 replies →

  • ajzinsbwbs  6 years ago

    Most people are going to hear the story on the radio or in a podcast app / RSS feed. It’s useful to have the story indexed on a shareable web link where it can be played on different platforms without any setup. If I wanted to share a podcast episode with friends in a group chat, a link like this would be a good way to do it. Since this is more of a long-form text discussion forum I’d probably look for a text format before posting here.