Comment by dragonwriter
5 years ago
> To deceive someone is to tell them an untruth for personal gain.
No, it's to cause someone to believe something that is not true.
Personal gain is a common goal served by deceit, not part of it's essential character.
Causing someone to believe something that is not true is too weak of a definition for deceive. Consider the difference between telling someone a falsehood versus deceiving someone. There is a malicious intent behind deception, which is not present in falsehood.
> Causing someone to believe something that is not true is too weak of a definition for deceive
No, it's literally the definition of the word.
> Consider the difference between telling someone a falsehood versus deceiving someone.
The difference is intent; if you don't know that it's false, or you don't intend it to be believed, it's not deception.
> There is a malicious intent behind deception,
It certainly is a matter of intent, but aside from the sense in which a false belief itself is a harm, and any intentional element of harm even if not a net harm is “malice”, I wouldn't say it is necessary malicious.
If you are referring to the dictionary definition of the word, then let me refer you to my experience learning different languages. The dictionary never fully captures the nuances of a word. I've had to get detailed explanations of different words where they all have the same definition, but are all used in different contexts. So technically deception means telling an untruth, if you limit yourself to dictionary definitions. But we live in a world where the nuances make or break kingdoms, and nobody reads text with only the dictionary definitions in mind.
Of course, based on your exposure to various literature, you might have a different feel for what the nuances of the word deception are, and maybe it matches exactly with the dictionary definition. But based on my experience, deception is a heavily negative word with malicious intent behind it.