← Back to context

Comment by ukyrgf

5 years ago

Include the full sentence.

> Of the 483,127 PRs submitted during Hacktoberfest, only 23,299 (4.82%) were identified as spam, with 19,587 (84.07%) of those being in a repository that the Hacktoberfest team excluded from the competition for not following the shared values and 3,712 (15.93%) being labeled as "invalid" by project maintainers.

Spam submissions were sent to spam repositories, that hasn't been known for years.

From the article, they act like it's their burden alone:

> Their solution, per their FAQ, is to put the burden solely on the shoulders of maintainers.

But, as a contributor, I see plenty of links for me all over Hacktoberfest to report repositories that are also trying to skirt the system.

One of the repos that I manage actively participates in Hacktoberfest and I'm finding out about this "invalid" label counting now, via this article.

No, I didn't read the FAQ, but I imagine neither did a lot of maintainers, especially those that don't participate. The undercounting must be massive.