← Back to context

Comment by tremon

4 years ago

How would you feel about researchers delivering known-faulty-under-some-conditions AoA sensors to Boeing, just to see if Boeing's QA process would catch those errors before final assembly?

I would feel that you are switching analogies...

This analogy is pretty valid, the in-flight-experiment analogy is invalid.

  • Is it? Linux underpins many medical devices - it too could lead to life and death consequences

    • You are ignoring the problematic experiment's methodology, which explicitly prevents the problematic patches from making it in by drawing attention to the vulnerability after they are accepted.

      Now, if this protocol were not followed, that's a different story, but we do not know this to be the case.

      2 replies →

I would feel that I'm wasting time that I could be using to find out why Boeing makes this possible (or any other corporate or government body with a critical system).