Comment by runevault
5 years ago
Uncle Bob himself acts like it is a bible, so if you buy into the rest of his crap then you'll likely buy into that too.
If treated as guidelines you are correct Clean Code is only eh instead of garbage. But taken in the full context of how it is presented/intended to be taken by the author it is damaging to the industry.
I've read his blog and watched his videos. While his attitude comes off as evangelical, his actual advice is very often "Do it when it makes sense", "There are exceptions - use engineering judgment", etc.
In no way is he treating his book as a bible.