Comment by 0xy

>That’s not entirely true

That's why I said it's not inherently illegal. Of course, if you have a folder called "porn" that is full of naked children it modifies the context and therefore the classification. But, if it's in a folder called "Beach Holiday 2019", it's not illegal nor really morally a problem. I'm dramatically over-simplifying of course. "It depends" all the way down.

>That’s a bold blanket statement

You're right, I shouldn't have been so broad. It's possible but unlikely, especially if it's not shared on social media.

It reinforces my original point however, because I can easily see a case where there's a totally voluntary nudist family who posts to social media getting caught up in a damaging investigation because of this. If their pictures end up in the possession of unsavory people and gets lumped into NCMEC's database then it's entirely possible they get flagged dozens or hundreds of times and get referred to police. Edge case, but a family is still destroyed over it. Some wrongfully accused people have their names tarnished permanently.

This kind of policy will lead to innocent people getting dragged through the mud. For that reason alone, this is a bad idea.