Comment by southerntofu
5 years ago
> Most people don't care that it takes an extra 10-100 milliseconds for the UI
TLDR: up to 100ms latency is fine, but alongside higher RAM usage, and when applied to all programs across your machine (not just a single app), hell breaks loose.
I entirely agree with this statement. However, most people don't have a high-end machine like the developers test on, and actual difference in latency between an electron app and a web app may be over an order of magnitude larger.
The problem is in many parts of the world (including in poorer communities of the global north) people rely on second-hand hardware which even in 2021 typically has 1-4GB of RAM, so a single application taking hundreds of megabytes when not over a gigabyte of RAM will quickly lead to you swap hell and render your entire machine slower.
Despite being an ardent GNU/Linux user, I believe the linux kernel OOM is close to the worst that can be done in this matter (although there are certain progresses with eg. earlyoom), but MacOS and Windows are certainly not immune from it. You'd be surprised just how much people avoid using their computer altogether when they don't absolutely need it, just because it's slow as hell, just because developers in their ~ivory towers~ offices didn't do testing on reasonable second-hand hardware.
I don't understand in which universe 100ms latency is fine. It's an insane amount of time. Hell, when you're used to 140+hz refresh rate, apps that have hardcoded a 60fps GUI refresh loop, so 16ms between two frames, are terribly obvious (and really feel like a pain to use)
It's not good, but it's not the worst. Of course i prefer applications which feel instantaneous, but these are hard to come by nowadays. I don't have strong opinions for 140Hz refresh rate, because i don't think i ever had monitors with more than 60Hz.
Many modern JS/Electron apps are in fact network bound for UI updates which is the worst possible thing you can do... just try to use element.io in a Tor Browser on a normal xDSL connection and you'll see what i mean (unless it's improved recently). So on this scale of the absurdity of modern software engineering, 100ms latency for user interaction is not all that bad... although my GUI/CLI tools in the 90s were much snappier than that and we have in fact greatly regressed as a field.
> Many modern JS/Electron apps
made my blood boil every time I had to use them. Even the poster child for a good Electron app, VS code, while packed with cool features, feels so sluggish next to Qt Creator that it distracts me from my work constantly when I use it.
Thankfully, on my Linux desktop, the actual number of such apps I actually need is precisely zero, everything has at least one (much snappier) Qt or GTK alternative.
> just try to use element.io in a Tor Browser on a normal xDSL connection and you'll see what i mean (unless it's improved recently).
I just tried without Tor and counted 5-6 seconds between the time where I clicked on "Open in your browser" and the page actually showing up here: https://element.io/get-started, so I'll happily pass