Comment by Dah00n
4 years ago
Not that I disagree that what we have today is a big mess but this sounds to me almost like the philosophy behind the old PHP version that everyone seems to hate. Personally I'd much rather have everything separated in a better HTML/CSS/JS than HTML+CSS+JS in one big pile. But I'm also not a fan of JavaScript at all, especially not of the hyped "one framework today, another tomorrow" that is JS development today. In my opinion in that area we are moving backwards very quickly.
Totally disagree as someone who grew up building websites as “cleanly” as possible, and now has spent many years doing all in one: the all in one is simply better in every way, it logically makes much more sense to group by component than by arbitrary style/structure/logic which just isn’t the right separation for many reasons that are written more fully in many places.
I also made SnackUI to solve the last problems of fully inline styles: namely to make them work 100% between React Native and Web, to make them extract to atomic CSS on web automatically, to optimize even conditionals into CSS, and finally to make media queries and themes work the same between Native/Web. We’re launching a very large app with it here in not long, and I absolutely love how clear it is to work on.
https://github.com/snackui/snackui
I think we're well past the period of a new framework every week - at least in a "real world" sense. Nearly all companies will settle on react or vue these days with a long tail choosing others, but this is no different than any other part of software development - lots of different databases, web frameworks, auth libraries etc all exist as well and are used.
Most of these "new" frameworks are more because someone wanted to scratch an itch or solve a specific problem they had, and frontend code simply lends itself well to being open sourced. If you don't like the new js tools that are made, just ignore them.