Comment by MontyCarloHall
4 years ago
In my experience, basic coding skills can really atrophy in senior developers who quit writing code years ago and are full-time architects/managers.
I’ve interviewed more than a handful of extremely accomplished people with decades of experience as developers and then engineering managers who couldn’t answer extremely basic coding questions (we’re talking “efficiently find duplicates in a list” or “compute Fibonacci numbers” basic). These people never could get past the O(n^2) brute force solution for finding duplicates (or the brute force compute every Fibonacci number starting from 1, 1), because they hadn’t thought about even basic algorithmic complexity in so long. And when people like this are giving orders from the top, you can see how software can get so slow.
I have no doubt that when these people were actually still coding, they could have answered my questions in their sleep. Quitting coding for engineering management really does one a disservice IMO. To this article’s point, I’ve also had the pleasure of working with people with decades of experience who never quit coding even as senior managers and their level of competence and productivity is astounding.
This is why I am considering leaving my current position. "oh we have something you can work on, but first can you..." 3 straight years of this...
I really cannot fathom how one could forget fundamentals.
I can prove the average complexity of quicksort with simple math transformations of initial recurrence equation which I do not even have remembered but I'm sure I could derive. Last time I did this was maybe 8 years ago if not more.
Yet somehow an accomplished dev cannot spot accidentally quadratic behavior when coding in something that is not Haskell.
IMO, the average dev and average accomplished dev is no longer the kind that knows the fundamentals. Not that it's necessary in all cases but eventually everything will look an equivalent of a doctoral thesis when the average codes the spaghetti mess.
Recently I was reviewing code with map(find).sort(indexOf) (O(n^2 log n + n^2) behavior) when it could have been a simple dict; map(dict.get) (O(n)). This person has 10 years of coding experience. When looking at the resume, the dev is pretty accomplished, productive, and worthy of the salary. But I assume the knowledge of fundamentals was missing from the start.