Comment by kuu
4 years ago
If pool is curated by moderators and dang is the only moderator, does it mean that pool is actually dang selection?
:)
4 years ago
If pool is curated by moderators and dang is the only moderator, does it mean that pool is actually dang selection?
:)
I'm not the only moderator, and there are a few non-moderators who also contribute to pool selection.
I'd really like to open that mechanism up to the community but it's still not obvious how to make that work well. Most ways of doing it would just recreate the voting system, and we already have one of those.
> I'm not the only moderator
I misunderstood the article and translated "main" to "only". Thanks for the clarification!
It's possible for HN readers to make suggestions for the pool, and I'll do this periodically.
Usually it's for a story which simply died in queue, which as TFA notes, is the default. Occasionally it's to see if a discussion might get "re-railed" after it's gone off on some tangent --- people responding to a title or an early comment, most often.
I don't nominate my own posts, of course.
It may be a matter of how many such nominations occur, but I'd say my success rate is >50% in having those accepted.
TL;DR: it's not just dang, and normal HN'ers can participate.
It's nicest when people don't nominate their own posts, but plenty of users do that as well.
I didn't know we could do that. What's the process for nominating a story?
I'll just email with a title "2nd-chance nomination: story-ID title"
And include the link in the post.
The story-ID is the numeric part of the post URL.
For this thread, where the post URL is
The story-ID is 29024032
(Moderators can use the story-ID via browser extensions / bookmarklets, I just learned yesterday.)
Similarly, include the story-ID for other issues (e.g., editorialised or clickbait title, suggesting a canonical URL, vouching flagged stories, spam).