← Back to context

Comment by jedberg

5 years ago

Quite possibly, but they should still have an alternative other than "impersonate someone else".

Any alternative would have to be inconvenient by design in order to work though, that's why phone numbers are used in the first place.

An effective verification system usually involves money at the root; verification in the style of phone verification works using proof of ownership of a limited resource, and most limited resources cost money (phone numbers, IPv4 addresses, etc).

In the real world this is analogous to charging money for access to an event purely in order to ensure it's not overrun with attendees,improving the experience for people who care enough to pay to get in. There are similar downsides to this; people who don't have money are left out.

Why not? It still limits bot creation (same number can only be used every 6 months). They don't actually want to know if the number belongs to you. Not much different than using a burner number.

  • Not everyone has a friend with a phone that doesn't use discord that they can use.

    • > Not everyone has a friend with a phone that doesn't use discord that they can use.

      I believe Discord can afford to ignore those 3 people. Not saying it's convenient for the user, but it's not enough of an issue to encourage Discord to find a solution.