Comment by rchaud
4 years ago
> No, this is not true. That's why most people on this site are not logging in through Google. Sites will store their own data, and if you trust them to store that data there’s really no reason to just trust them to store a link to your identity.
You're missing the point. Yes, we don't need oAuth to log into HN. But HN is a site that is over 15 years old, and reflects the technology of its time. Instead, look at the companies YC funds and ask yourself how many of them DON'T have oAuth/SSO of some kind. Reddit is roughly HN's age, and you can see that with the introduction of VC money and profit goals, they've shifted towards discouraging anonymous logins. My 10-year old Reddit account doesn't even have an email associated with it; I doubt that's allowed now.
The old web made by hobbyists having fun and not trying to sell anything is long gone. Even sites like HN are disappearing, and everything IS being monetized, whether we like it or not.
I don't understand your point.
Even if HN used oAuth - even if they required oAuth - ultimately oAuth, oAuth as implemented on most sites is just a thin layer over email so you don't have to make another account.
The problem doesn't require blockchain as a solution. What would the website administrator gain from accepting a blockchain login? People would create accounts but you have no way of contacting them since you have no email. Clearly the kinds of sites you're describing wouldn't accept that.
OK so you associate an email with your blockchain login - so now it's the same as the status quo. What's the point?
> Reddit is roughly HN's age, and you can see that with the introduction of VC money and profit goals, they've shifted towards discouraging anonymous logins.
And what, you think they'll be okay with anonymous users if those users log in with web3?
If they log in with a crypto wallet, that massively reduces the friction of making payments, which is all that investors want.
Reddit wants users to be somewhat identifiable in order to play to advertisers. However if people start buying and selling goods on Reddit itself (e.g. subscriptions to private subreddits), the company wouldn't have to rely as heavily on advertising.
> I doubt that's allowed now.
It is. You have to hit next when prompted to enter an email address when registering (the input is not required)
Actually, I wish all of the internet had the simplicity and no-bullshit approach to information consumption that HN offers. RSS, simple login, text based - it's ideal.