Comment by sundarurfriend

Yeah, Julia can only take metaprogramming so far given its non-S-expr syntax - which is the right tradeoff given its domain. Its macros have to be given at least vaguely Julia-like syntax - `*` still needs to be a binary operator, `if`s need `end`s, etc. That's great for nice little DSLs appropriate for the scientific domain, but not quite enough for a "platform for programming languages". (It also has "string macros", which can accept anything at all, but basically give you a lump of string at compile time, and leave the tokenization, parsing, and any further manipulation up to your macro.)