← Back to context

Comment by Noughmad

3 years ago

It's actually quite simple. The government can buy things services from specific providers, but it cannot force you to buy services from specific providers. In other words, it can buy BMWs for government use, but it cannot say "you have to buy a BMW to enter the municipal office".

The same applies to websites. If a government website uses Google analytics, it is essentially requiring you to do business with a specific company (in this case Google) in order to use a government service.

12 comments

Noughmad

Reply
inlined  3 years ago

And if the government uses Cloudflare or GoDaddy or aws it’s requiring you to do business with those companies. This goal is impossible to achieve with any government run service.

  • kevincox  3 years ago

    It's easy. You just need the government to run fiber to every citizens house so that the can connect directly to the government data center.

    Of course some citizens are living over seas so we can provide a satellite uplink for them.

  • Noughmad  3 years ago

    No, those do not see any benefit from me visiting the site beyond what the government is paying them for. Analytics does, they get my data.

Arainach  3 years ago

If the government takes your data and runs an analysis on an old IBM mainframe, are they forcing you to do business with IBM?

  • Phrodo_00  3 years ago

    Is this a bad faith argument? I can't see how the difference of google having the data vs the government (or whatever entity you interacted directly with) is so easy to miss.

wutbrodo  3 years ago

Could you expand on the definition of "doing business with" an entity that you're using here? It seems quite non-standard.

If you open the door to a govt office, are you doing business with the company who installed the doors? If you use the toilet, are you doing business with the company that janitorial services are contracted out to?

  • Levitz  3 years ago

    No, when you leave that govt office you don't have any link to those companies.

    When you visit a site with Google Analytics, they still have your data after you leave.

    • wutbrodo  3 years ago

      I see, I think framing it as "doing business" threw me off. Semantics aside, this distinction is meaningful.

jollybean  3 years ago

This analogy does not apply.

The gov. is using some service and therefore some citizen data is subject to the T&C's and that's it.

If Google were a German or UK company it would be the same thing - everyone subject to those T&C's.