Comment by lmm

> I know we're all hot and bothered about getting our apps to scale up to be the next unicorn, but most apps never need to scale past the limit of a single very high-performance database. For most people, this single huge DB is sufficient.

True if the reliability is good enough. I agree that many organisations will never get to the scale where they need it as a performance/data size measure, but you often will grow past the reliability level that's possible to achieve on a single node. And it's worth saying that the various things that people do to mitigate these problems - read replicas, WAL shipping, and all that - can have a pretty high operational cost. Whereas if you just slap in a horizontal autoscaling datastore with true master-master HA from day 1, you bypass all of that trouble and just never worry about it.

> Also, for many (maybe even most) applications, designated outages for maintenance are not only acceptable, but industry standard. Banks have had, and continue to have designated outages all the time, usually on weekends when the impact is reduced.

IME those are a minority of applications. Anything consumer-facing, you absolutely do lose out (and even if it's not a serious issue in itself, it makes you look bush-league) if someone can't log into your system at 5AM on Sunday. Even if you're B2B, if your clients are serving customers then they want you to be online whenever their customers are.