← Back to context

Comment by chiefalchemist

3 years ago

It's all in the name: The United States. States is the key word.

No one is suggesting horses or written email.

It's a simple understanding of history, and a practical and honest observation of how dysfunctional things continue to be. Yet we keep pushing that the answer is more of the same? That's naive. That's not sustainable.

We certainly need to improve.

I am not convinced in the "go back to the way it was designed" argument, since you either have to cherry pick the aspects you like, or advocate for reversing women's suffrage, emancipation of slaves, etc.

As soon as we agree that the founders got some things right and some things wrong, there is no more argument that they were prescient and we should revert to their designs.

IMO better to take stock of the current situation and seek changes based on their merits today, independently of whether they align to the ideas of 250 years ago.