← Back to context

Comment by amelius

3 years ago

I don't get the strong/weak link analogy.

Supposedly, you have a chain with links. The weakest link breaks first.

Now what kind of chain would have its strongest link break first?

Anyway, we might as well call this min/max problems.

Yeah, I wish the author had spent a paragraph shoring up the flawed analogy. Here's how I did it in my head:

Normally, chains have their links in series, in which case the chain breaks when the weakest link breaks. Now imagine two objects connected directly by many links, i.e. a parallel chain. This is a "strongest link chain" where just one strong link, or a few strong links, can hold the two objects together even if most of the links break.

  • Yes this seems the way to think about it, but on the other hand linking two objects with many weak links will generally result in a strong link, because the force divides between them.