← Back to context

Comment by jstarfish

3 years ago

What a shitshow.

> Stivers received an email from her professor indicating that a portion of it had been flagged by Turnitin as AI-written

> Last month, a Texas professor incorrectly used ChatGPT in trying to assess whether students had completed an assignment using that software. It claimed to have written every essay he fed in — so he temporarily withheld a whole class’ final grades.

> William Quarterman, a senior and history major at the college. A professor had run his exam answers through an AI detection called GPTZero, which returned a positive result. The professor gave Quarterman a failing grade and referred him to the same student affairs office

Let's let professors indict students based on untested (and amateur) AI algorithms that not even the vendors completely comprehend and subject the accused to a process in which they are presumed guilty until they prove their innocence-- while they mortgage their future paying 5 to 6 figures for the privilege.

These are the real AI "safety" issues that need to be addressed. The only "danger" posed by AI is in its total lack of accountability. This is outright abusive behavior on the part of colleges, who wasted no time in weaponizing it to conduct virtual arbitration. The irony of an AI system flagging students for copying what someone else wrote is apparently lost on everyone.

Any sensible schools should have plagiarism allegations reviewed by a committee where due process is followed. The professor should not allowed to just give a failing grade on personal belief.

I'm kinda appalled that many professors have jumped on the GPT bandwagon so quickly, claiming it should be part of the standard curriculum and how we should have it as the foundation of academic programs, going forward. I don't really understand their lack of critical thinking on the use of this unproven tech, at all. Makes me really doubt their competence as an educator and an academic.

  • > Makes me really doubt their competence as an educator and an academic.

    Lol, happens everywhere, power of memes and all that. Only difference is you know more about ChatGPT than them.

    • I’m not sure I know more, but they like to and are incentivized to dream perhaps quite a bit more than needed.