← Back to context

Comment by donatj

3 years ago

When mentioning `open` they should have noted that `open <file>` will open the given file with its associated app.

It’s indispensable.

6 comments

donatj

Reply
lloeki  3 years ago

More than that, it sends a message to launchd/the app instead of forking on the spot.

Sadly the app does get the shell's environment and it can't be disabled:

     Opened applications inherit environment variables just as if you had
     launched the application directly through its full path.  This behavior
     was also present in Tiger.

Why this matters, e.g with vscode:

    - ensure vscode is fully closed
    - enter project directory, something sets vars in your shell (you manually or automatically via direnv)
    - code .
    - vscode process now has the env from the shell it was started
    - open another directory from the UI
    - vscode forks and inherits from its parent process, thus the other project window has the original shell's env
    - go to another directory
    - code .
    - vscode finds out it's already running, forks and opens another window. this window has the original shell env
    - fully quit vscode and reopen it, but via the app in /Applications
    - vscode opens, now has a blank environment for its main process, and forks form there to restore previous windows, which now lack the environment they had

It's a) completely inconsistent and b) dangerous: imagine the original shell had a setting or secret in an env var that was shared to the second project (e.g virtualenv, deploy target, deployment key...)

The same issue can happen with other apps but also tmux (the tmux daemon is spawned from the first tmux command, and then subsequent sessions from tmux-server; doing it another way is possible but nontrivial)

https://github.com/microsoft/vscode/issues/15452

https://github.com/microsoft/vscode/issues/108804#issuecomme...

computerfriend  3 years ago

Especially

    open .

if you need to drag a file somewhere. One thing that kind of breaks my muscle memory here is the opposite, something like

    firefox file.html

doesn't work and you have to fiddle with the arguments to get open to launch a non-default application.

  • zora_goron  3 years ago

    I use `open .` to open up a Finder window of the directory I'm currently in using Terminal so frequently that I've set up an alias for it --

      alias op='open .'

    • ojosilva  3 years ago

      It took me a while but I finally got open to open folders in a new Finder tab instead of opening a new window each time.

           function opent () {
        what=${1:-`pwd`}
        what=$(cd "$what"; pwd)
        osascript -e "tell application \"Finder\"
        activate
        set t to target of Finder window 1
        set toolbar visible of window 1 to true
        end tell
        tell application \"System Events\"
        keystroke \"t\" using command down
        end tell
        tell application \"Finder\"
        set target of Finder window 1 to POSIX file \"$what\"
        end tell" > /dev/null
    }

    ## opens current dir
    $ opent .
    ## same
    $ opent

lattalayta  3 years ago

I also find myself using open -n -a <application> to open a new separate instance of an application if I want to copy settings from one file to another or work on two files with separate instances of a program