Comment by tensor
2 years ago
Of course you have to consider what other countries will do when you create your laws. The notion that you can ignore the rest of the world is both naive and incredibly arrogant.
There are plenty of technologies that absolutely do not "make the world better" but unfortunately must get built because humans are shitty to each other. Weapons are the obvious one, but not the only one. Often countries pass laws to encourage certain technologies or productions so as not to get outcompeted or outproduced by other countries.
The argument here about AI is exactly this sort of argument. If other countries build vastly superior AI by have fewer developmental restrictions, then your country maybe both at a military disadvantage but also at an economic disadvantage because you can be easily outproduced by countries using vastly more efficient technology.
You must balance all the harms and benefits when making laws, including external to the country issues.
I don't think the government is talking about AI for weapons. of course that will be allowed. It's the US, we have the right to kill people. Just not make fake porn videos of them.