← Back to context

Comment by skitout

2 years ago

You do point some interesting points.

Note that the issue in not the Nakba anymore. From memory Oslo was about giving to a demilitarize Palestinian state about 10% of the Palestine mandate territory mostly in "islands" controlled by Israel, then progressively over a long period, increasing it to 22%, with quite no hope to get East Jerusalem back. And now (even before oct. 7) that seems impossible, far too much for the Israelis. (in 1992 89% of the population was "Palestinian")

In general westerners don't care about what happen abroad when there is nothing connected to them. In French media we have seen many stuff about Nagorno-Karabakh (with an Armenian point of view), because there are Armenian in France, and because it fits the narrative of the clash of civilizations Christian Vs Muslim. But it was far, in unimportant countries for us, few dead, no suspense, nothing spectacular...

Israel Palestine is another beast :

- Jerusalem in Holly for half of the world population and most westerners

- Israel as been important in US politics for decades (partly because of the first point) and the USA are direct and strong ally

- Most non western country have been colonized or assaulted by westerners in "recent" history... This conflict is also the echo and symbol of this : westerners assaulting non westerners (while giving moral lesson to the world)

- For some westerners that is the echo of Muslim and terrorists attacking westerners - us (9 11, Paris attack are in all minds), and for some kind of a symbol of the clash of civilization

- And this is happening now, with a lot of pictures, media coverage, with new images everyday, some suspense, some twist...

Now that I think about it, one salient distinction might be that Palestinian refugees became largely stateless after their expulsion. The Arab states didn't want them (and still don't, no matter what they say), and there was nowhere for them to go in Palestine besides the refugee camps. Most expelled ethnic refugees have a homeland willing to receive them, or at least sympathetic nations willing to give them asylum.