← Back to context

Comment by mort96

1 year ago

I guess I just wish the HN timeline wasn't so full of his garbage.

I use starlink, it works pretty well, as good as cable. Not garbage.

I've ridden in Teslas. Some likes, but holy shit that drivetrain. Not garbage.

You however, have been consuming garbage media. Hint: if every other day (ahem Gawker sites) there is an outrageous anti-Musk headline or "crazy thing Musk said" headline, your media source is total garbage.

Is he a "good guy"? No. Is he "the worse thing ever?" No. What does it matter what he says or does? Nothing. Yet he is living in seemingly millions of people's brains as the sum factor of dozens of PR and advertising campaigns, in addition to the general anti-intellectualism of America.

Anyway, Starlink is a transformative data provider service that blankets virtually the entire world in broadband class connectivity, including massive amounts of third world countries and other areas.

Calling it garbage is dumb.

  • Agree to disagree I guess. The fact that it's his project makes it uninteresting even if the tech would have been alright in the hands of someone less harmful.

    If you aren't catching things like his signal boosting of literal nazis on Twitter, your media sources are garbage. (Also is Gawker even still a thing?)

    • on one hand

      - Tesla kicked off one of the two pillars of dealing with climate change: EVs to eliminate as much carbon emissions from transportation as possible

      on the other hand

      - mean tweets

      ... yes there is a lot of hard work by other people involved in #1, but Musk's leadership was a major contributor. Let me ask you a question. Rank the most evil CEOs in the world. If you have musk over petroleum companies, mining executives, military contractors, gun manufacturers, internet companies hoovering your data for the government, financial wizards defrauding people for short term gain, etc, then I'm sorry, you don't know anything about the world. Oops, I forgot purdue pharma and other opioid producers, chemicals and industrialists that dump and poison the environment, surveillance and security companies enabling despots (and the US government), I mean, I could go on.

      2 replies →

Do you have a specific qualms with satellites providing internet to remote areas or EVs or space exploration or is it purely personal?

In other words, what makes it "garbage" to you?

If it's straight up due to Musk being involved, isn't that a negative outlook for the sake of being negative?

You could just view it as humans advancing and be happy about that.

It is not HIS garbage. He is involved in numerous companies. Starlink is a product of SpaceX and that is full of thousands of great engineers. To be disinterested in SpaceX technology because of Musk is to be completely dismissive of the amazing accomplishments and effort of those thousands of great engineers. Would you like to have your work dismissed because the head of your company was a bizarre jerk? By any rational measure, SpaceX is NOT producing garbage tech.

  • Those thousands of great engineers at SpaceX decided to dedicate their lives to do Musk's bidding. Not my fault.