← Back to context

Comment by tcfhgj

2 years ago

Signal isn't a step up, because it centralizes communication.

(linearized) Matrix would be a step up.

Matrix is strongly persistent, thin client; Signal is ephemeral, thin server. They cannot replace each other.

  • It doesn't really matter, because you can replace SMS with linearized Matrix. Signal can't, because it's centralized

    • Signal the protocol can be and is implemented by third parties. Signal the platform, is different. Keep in mind Signal's only centralised part is thin server that acts as a relay. Matrix is a thin client protocol that relies on server to enforce soundness rules.

      1 reply →