← Back to context

Comment by luuurker

8 months ago

I remember them criticising Google for not being faster at removing cached files. I don't remember them blaming Google for their screw up.

And let's be honest, if a big provider wants to offer cached versions of pages, they probably should have a way to purge those files in case there's a problem (eg: malware).

> I don't remember them blaming Google for their screw up.

You're putting words into my mouth.

  • I'm not sure what you were expecting people to take away from your message, with the way that it is worded. It may not have been the intent, but the particular way you expressed your point heavily implies it.

    • > I'm not sure what you were expecting people to take away from your message, with the way that it is worded.

      My guess would be that they were saying that Cloudflare's HN comment on the incident was to complain about google not cleaning up after the incident.

      > the particular way you expressed your point heavily implies it.

      You can't turn around the burden of proof this easily. Saying "the particular way you expressed it" doesn't give you license to make things up about a comment that is an inch above yours.

      1 reply →

  • Um, you literally wrote:

         ... the CEO’s strategy was to turn up here and criticise Google for not deindexing quickly enough.
    

    Isn't that "them blaming Google for their screw up"?