Comment by Dylan16807
2 years ago
> unless the bar for "bad company" is a lot higher than I see it.
Yes, the bar is higher (higher means it's harder to qualify as bad, right?) when talking about needing to quit.
> I already asserted at the very beginning of the comment chain, almost every company is bad. That went unchallenged
Because you went on to say it didn't matter anyway, so I focused on the latter part of your post.
Though I'm confused. You showed an argument that sorting companies into good and bad results in absurdity, but it only results in absurdity when the bar is super low. Why is your conclusion that sorting is impossible, rather than "the bar is too low", if you were already seriously considering that the bar needs to be higher?
I don't think the bar should be higher for bad deeds! I prefer a lower bar. I see a lot of stuff happen in the world that I really don't want to happen (on topic: privacy invasions for profit), and it's not publicly called bad nearly enough.
I also thinks it's misleading and not very useful to call people good or bad, in general. I'm more comfortable with calling capitalist corporations "bad" as a blanket statements; resource-hoarding is their utmost priority, and I consider that an evil motivation.
My conclusion isn't that sorting is impossible, it's that people are too complex to be sorted into "good" and "bad", in general... and that it's shitty and incorrect to call ordinary people bad if they aren't willing to risk everything to work for a slightly less evil company in a world made of evil companies.
Well this just sounds like more reason to use a point scale rather than calling the entire idea a waste of time.
In particular 'slightly less evil' is not the goal.
> Well this just sounds like more reason to use a point scale rather than calling the entire idea a waste of time.
Again, I think we're kind of on the same page, but our solutions are different. The original question refused any kind of nuance, and we both seem to agree it's not a question that should ignore nuance. You choose to answer a binary question with a grading system, I choose to substitute a different question.
1 reply →