← Back to context

Comment by K0balt

2 years ago

The property (“bug”) in question is an inherent and intentional property of meekly-tree type storage systems such as git.

Calling this a bug is like reporting that telnet sends information unencrypted.

The actual bug is in the way that their UX paradigm sets user expectations.

4 comments

K0balt

Reply
yencabulator  2 years ago

Don't blame Git for Github decisions.

Github chooses to store all "Github forks" in the same repository, and allow accessing things in that repository even when they are not reachable by the refs in the namespace of one "fork". That is purely a Github decision.

  • K0balt  2 years ago

    They could have split forks off into new repos, but then they wouldn’t be forks, in the repository sense. It was never hard to just copy a repo instead of forking it. The UX just leads people into holding it wrong.