Comment by jcgrillo
1 month ago
I could see this being extremely valuable to law enforcement if they're planning on making an arrest. They're a lot more likely to not get shot by the suspect if they know they're asleep. It's also the sort of thing that's not germane to making their case against the suspect--it's tactically relevant but strategically irrelevant. So we need something more than the 4th amendment here? That's actually a question I'm not a lawyer and don't know what this actually implies. Naively, it seems to me that if information is inadmissible in making their case, law enforcement should have no access to it and, probably, neither should anyone else.
That only would matter on no knock warrants, right? That’s the best case I can think of (still bad imo, I think no knock warrants are abused and lead to bad outcomes more often than good ones).
Yeah I agree it all adds up to nothing good.
> They're a lot more likely to not get shot by the suspect if they know they're asleep.
Are they even? Or, can they know that? If the suspect has a gun, they'll wake up scared, confused, and with every reason to believe somebody's illegally breaking and entering.
Her name was Breonna Taylor, she was an emergency medical technician until police shot her. #sayHerName
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Killing_of_Breonna_Taylor