Comment by nwiswell
1 day ago
> It realistically affects practically nobody alive
Do people in the Global South not use GPS or consume weather forecasts?
1 day ago
> It realistically affects practically nobody alive
Do people in the Global South not use GPS or consume weather forecasts?
Sure, GPS is nice to have, but we lived without it for many centuries before it, it's also a "first-world-problem" if it goes down. GPS is also notoriously susceptible to ground-based jamming. And because of that there's also other ways to track position. Weather forecasts are nice to have, but often wrong. My original comment was framed more towards space travel.
The thing is that GPS doesn't just do positioning. If we lost GPS then we can just look at road signs (hopefully). GPS also provides time synchronization to a lot of very important telecom infrastructure. To prevent 4G base stations and digital TV transmitters from interfering with each other, their transmit reference clock frequency need to be disciplined to within 50 ppb and their time need to be synchronized to less then 1 us.
No GPS means no 4G and no digital TV. And technology leapfrog effect means that third world countries will be significantly affected, as they jumped directly to mobile phone: https://www.cio.com/article/194000/what-does-technology-leap... . And countries are moving toward digital TV from analog TV: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Digital_television_transition because they want to free up the spectrum for cellular network.
This is bad. The transmitter towers aren't moving anywhere soon, so the obvious solution is to move them to fiber timing network. Wired is always more reliable then wireless anyway, ask Linus Tech Tips. Only China understands this though: https://www.gpsworld.com/china-finishing-high-precision-grou... and https://cpl.iphy.ac.cn/article/10.1088/0256-307X/41/6/064202 . EU is moving toward that: https://www.gpsworld.com/europe-moving-toward-a-timing-backb... . US is hopeless
And technology leapfrog effect means that third world countries will be significantly affected
Exactly that. In many parts of Africa the middle of nowhere is full of people. In many places mobile phones are the only way to get internet. I can't wait for starlink to be available here. Getting internet is not a first world problem.
> Weather forecasts are nice to have, but often wrong.
I think you are really, really underestimating the importance of weather forecasting to modern agriculture (and therefore global stability), shipping and transport, logistics, energy infrastructure, and on and on.