← Back to context

Comment by vundercind

1 year ago

> Also large amounts of crime in NY goes unreported because people mind their business and/or don't trust the cops.

Yes, crime stats are a mess for a bunch of reasons. The most-reliable are murder stats, because they rarely go unreported or otherwise unnoticed, and are the hardest to "juke the stats" on, especially if you try to do it for more than a brief span of time. Those are better in scary ol' Manhattan than in much of "safe" small town, small city, and suburban America, and often way better.

per-capita. NYC still has like 400-500 murders a year. That's a small area. That's as many as happen in my whole state.

  • ... but per-capita is 100% of what matters when assessing risk...?

    [EDIT] Assessing risk based on course crime stats, I mean. Of course individual context and situations matter a lot, too.

    • Not really. Proximity is important. It influences how many people are going to be affected by it.

      Getting murdered on my front lawn is a lot different than getting murdered in the lobby of a housing complex with 1000 people living in it.

      Density is even more important when considering random crime because you have even more people who will be potential victims when someone is targeting an area.

      1 reply →