Comment by chrismorgan

> Browsers do not want to render a window that is over a trillion trillion pixels high, so I needed to handle scrolling and rendering on my own

What’s fun is what actually happens when you try to do these things. It’s disappointing, you can’t even get anywhere near one trillion pixels.

The limits I found five years ago when working at Fastmail, after a customer using IE found their scrollbar broke when they had around 200,000 emails in a mailbox (plus I just checked a couple of them again now):

• Firefox: a few years ago, ignored declarations that resolved to a value higher than 17,895,697 pixels (a smidgeon under 2³⁰ sixtieth pixels). Now, it clamps at that point instead, but maybe three pixels more or less, not immediately clear quite what’s going on and I can’t be bothered investigating. (All browsers seem to have inconsistencies in how clientHeight/getBoundingClientRect/dev tools/whatever report things, that close to the boundaries of possibility. It’s mildly fascinating.)

• IE: ignores declarations that resolve to a value equal to or higher than 10,737,418.23 pixels (2³⁰ − 1 hundredth pixels).

• WebKit: clamps values somewhere around 2²⁵ (~33,554,432) pixels.

• Chromium: matched WebKit when I tested, now it’s clamping around 22,360,882 pixels, but I’m on a 1.5× display, so the 2²⁵ could be connected with device pixels or such. But I think I was on a 2× display when I did the initial testing!

See also https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34299569 where I wrote more about it, with links to relevant source code.