← Back to context

Comment by brandall10

5 days ago

"at the expense of communicating ideas with coherence and depth"

To be fair, while shorts is clearly designed to generate high virality and compete w/ TikTok, YouTube does incentivize longer form content. For regular videos the platform appears to optimize for engagement at about the 10 minute mark.

Political/social discourse is complex and I believe goes beyond a simple soundbite problem. One could argue this began with 24 hour news cycles with all the time in the world, and news had to become entertainment to fill the space. The movie "Network" presaged this sensationalized this culture situation well before it became a thing, and certainly well before social media was conceptualized.

> YouTube does incentivize long

If they only gave you the option to remove shorts from results...

  • And the stupid ass playables that they're spamming me with now. It's not enough that I pay for Premium.

  • oh there is an X on the top right corner of the shorts block on the website. but don't you believe clicking it will remove the block for more than a couple days. and you're right, the mobile website/app doesn't even have that