← Back to context

Comment by throw0101c

4 days ago

> No, the US is far better.

> Silence can’t be used against you.

As sibling comments have mentioned, not (no longer?) true.

"Opinion recap: If you want to claim the Fifth…"

> Because merely keeping quiet when police ask damaging questions is not claiming a right to silence, the Supreme Court ruled Monday, prosecutors may use that silence against the suspect at the trial. If an individual is voluntarily talking to the police, he or she must claim the Fifth Amendment right of silence, or lose it; simply saying nothing won’t do, according to the ruling.

* https://www.scotusblog.com/2013/06/opinion-recap-if-you-want...

"Silence as evidence: U.S. Supreme Court holds that the Fifth Amendment does not bar using a suspect’s silence as evidence of guilt"

* https://www.lexology.com/library/detail.aspx?g=61f0c293-44b7...

Er, what? This seems quite better than the UK where claiming the right can still cause it to be used against you...