← Back to context

Comment by donatj

4 days ago

It doesn't need to be better than TikTok though, just better than xiaohongshu

Maybe people developed a fetish for Chinese.

  • "Fetish" is the wrong way to look at it, but it does seem connected. The explanation I've seen is basically a unified "fuck you, I won't do what you tell me, so instead I'm going to give my data to China even harder". It's a generation of kids who grew up (mostly correctly) assuming all of their data was already all controlled by corporations in league with the government. Worrying about data privacy is too quaint to even consider.

    There's of course a chance of algorithmic meddling, nudging people to a different Chinese app, but I think spite is a far simpler answer.

    • > I've seen is basically a unified "fuck you ..."

      My wife is exploring RedNote for this very reason. "You're telling me I have an easy way to make the US government upset and the more I use RedNote, the more upset they are?" was her line of thinking. She explained that it makes her feel like she has a morsel of control over a group that previously didn't give a damn.

      Her father would also be upset if she starts learning Chinese because of his political tendencies. It's basically a two-for-one deal of learning about another culture and learning a foreign language.

    • I live in the US. I mean, if I give my data to China, what are they going to do, arrest me? Oh wait no, that's if I give my data to Google or Meta.

      15 replies →