Comment by WalterBright
3 days ago
The IRS disallows wash sale deductions if you reinvest in a substantially similar investment within 30 days.
I'm not an IRS agent and have no idea what they mean by substantially similar. You might want to talk to your tax accountant.
> substantially similar investment
They actually use the word 'identical' instead of 'similar', if that matters. It seems to be a grey area with ETFs, and I'm not a financial advisor, so won't make any further claims.
> You might want to talk to your tax accountant.
Absolutely agreed. You can also just let a reputable robo do it for you if you don't have the time or energy for it, there are multiple. It is what I ended up doing. It's modest but every bit helps.
Indeed, the wording is “substantially identical”, which is important. 2 different ETFs that track similar, but not identical indices (e.g. S&P500 vs Russell 1000 large cap, for example) are clearly not substantially identical, and make great tax-loss harvesting pairs. There’s tons of case law, opinions from tax experts, and automated tax-loss harvesting tools from a variety of brokers that agree with this viewpoint.
Robo advisors are intricately familiar with tax law? That's new to me.
US lets you claim $3k of capital losses each against income, so a robo advisor can optimize for this
IIRC they have never defined "substantially similar" and they don't actually go after people who sell etf X and immediately buy etf Y with an identical price graph