← Back to context Comment by rayiner 10 months ago [flagged] 8 comments rayiner Reply jakelazaroff 10 months ago Most countries wouldn't be in that position in the first place. Mexico attacking the US would be basically unprovoked; Hamas attacking Israel is… not. sempron64 10 months ago Before the attacks Israel was in the process of normalizing relations with Gaza. For example, they were increasing work permits monthly. Here is an article from summer 2022https://www.timesofisrael.com/liveblog_entry/bennett-said-to...The Nova music festival was a peace festival.So yes, the Oct 7th attack was unprovoked. Subjective historical context is not provocation. jakelazaroff 10 months ago An ongoing occupation and blockade is not historical context, it's present context. 3 replies → rayiner 10 months ago We literally took California, Nevada, Utah, Arizona, Wyoming, Colorado, New Mexico, and Texas from independent Mexico in a war. jakelazaroff 10 months ago …in the 1840s.
jakelazaroff 10 months ago Most countries wouldn't be in that position in the first place. Mexico attacking the US would be basically unprovoked; Hamas attacking Israel is… not. sempron64 10 months ago Before the attacks Israel was in the process of normalizing relations with Gaza. For example, they were increasing work permits monthly. Here is an article from summer 2022https://www.timesofisrael.com/liveblog_entry/bennett-said-to...The Nova music festival was a peace festival.So yes, the Oct 7th attack was unprovoked. Subjective historical context is not provocation. jakelazaroff 10 months ago An ongoing occupation and blockade is not historical context, it's present context. 3 replies → rayiner 10 months ago We literally took California, Nevada, Utah, Arizona, Wyoming, Colorado, New Mexico, and Texas from independent Mexico in a war. jakelazaroff 10 months ago …in the 1840s.
sempron64 10 months ago Before the attacks Israel was in the process of normalizing relations with Gaza. For example, they were increasing work permits monthly. Here is an article from summer 2022https://www.timesofisrael.com/liveblog_entry/bennett-said-to...The Nova music festival was a peace festival.So yes, the Oct 7th attack was unprovoked. Subjective historical context is not provocation. jakelazaroff 10 months ago An ongoing occupation and blockade is not historical context, it's present context. 3 replies →
jakelazaroff 10 months ago An ongoing occupation and blockade is not historical context, it's present context. 3 replies →
rayiner 10 months ago We literally took California, Nevada, Utah, Arizona, Wyoming, Colorado, New Mexico, and Texas from independent Mexico in a war. jakelazaroff 10 months ago …in the 1840s.
Most countries wouldn't be in that position in the first place. Mexico attacking the US would be basically unprovoked; Hamas attacking Israel is… not.
Before the attacks Israel was in the process of normalizing relations with Gaza. For example, they were increasing work permits monthly. Here is an article from summer 2022
https://www.timesofisrael.com/liveblog_entry/bennett-said-to...
The Nova music festival was a peace festival.
So yes, the Oct 7th attack was unprovoked. Subjective historical context is not provocation.
An ongoing occupation and blockade is not historical context, it's present context.
3 replies →
We literally took California, Nevada, Utah, Arizona, Wyoming, Colorado, New Mexico, and Texas from independent Mexico in a war.
…in the 1840s.