Comment by mind-blight

> When you embrace CSS as your primary architecture, you're not just writing styles - you're building a design system.

And

> Nue is of course not for everyone. It's specifically designed for developers who see CSS as a creative medium - who get excited about the possibilities of container queries, custom properties, and calc() functions. For these developers, CSS isn't just a styling language - it's a powerful system for expressing design.

Are both super interesting and make sense with a number of changes I've seen in the ecosystem. I respect CSS-focused developers (I'm not one, but I like to dabble) and appreciate a ton of innovation that's coming out of the designer-developers who try to push the boundaries of both the roles and the technology.

The disconnect that remains for me is that client/server state management and scope creep are the two main drivers of sprawling code bases in my experience. Having a bunch of 1-off styles in a component definitely made design updates a nightmare, but tailwind and/or just using CSS variables helped improve that. Using service-oriented architecture (including on the frontend to keep complex business logic out of components), GraphQL + fragments + urql/apollo, and/or Remix (or a similar framework) were all really big steps forward in trying to solve the thorny state management problem. They all come with their own tradeoffs, but that's where most of the complexity and sprawl comes from in my experience.

There's definite bloat from people re-inventing the wheel (forms are the most common one I encounter), but the explanation pages feel like Nue is a panacea. I only see how it improves specific areas rather than the whole architecture. I'll say, I really like how HTMX approached their education around this. Similarly, they're a "use the standards!" kind of library, but they have clear examples of what is solved, and what isn't solved. And their "isn't" includes cases where the current approach is better suited. That makes the scope a lot clearer, which I still feel like I'm missing from the Nue project

ETA:

It's also possible that I'm just not the target audience. Most of the projects I've built or lead have been either extremely event heavy (E.g. using Bluetooth sensors attached to limbs + timers to guide people step-by-step through exercises) or extremely data heavy (e.g. analytics and information collection based on dynamic ontologies). The data model and state management were always multiple orders of magnitude more complex than almost anything else.