← Back to context

Comment by whstl

1 day ago

Definitely the same for computers. LOTS of software rely on saving data on "secret" locations for shareware-style trials.

macOS for one has been asking to allow access to specific folders. Other OSs are possibly starting to do the same, but it used to be a free-for-all.

Linux has containers for this - firejail, flatpack and others have support for this.

Older software tended to be less obnoxious about it. I have never had a desktop app refuse to run for this sort of reason.

Desktop software installers do not claim to offer this security. Mobile OSes claim to be sandboxed so your expectations are different.

The sorts of applications you install are different too. Many mobile apps are things you would do using a web browser on a desktop. They should therefore be locked down the way webapps are.