← Back to context

Comment by LAC-Tech

4 months ago

Question: why pro-active block some authoritarian countries like the UK, but not others like China? Is it because only the UK passes legislation that threaten people outside of its borders? Or does China do it too and we ignore it?

China probably can’t get the USA to extradite an American citizen for breaking a Chinese law. The UK can.

  • The UK can't even get the USA to extradite an American woman who was driving on the wrong side of the road and killed a child.

    The US-USA extradition treaties have always been one way.

  • Are there any examples in history of the US extraditing someone with no UK ties to the UK?

    • If you commit a crime in the UK then I would expect extradition to be a genuine risk.

      It's a connected world, so online activities are probably pretty grey-areas. If you defraud someone (for example) but they're in another country, where did the crime happen?

  • Yeah that makes sense.

    I thought extradition laws usually had some kind of clause like "only applies if it'd be a crime in both jurisdictions", but now I think about that I can't remember where I heard that or why I think it so I will admit complete ignorance.