Comment by timmg
1 year ago
> We are no longer allowed or trusted to make choices in our best interests.
Ironically (or not) this is the Apple side of the Android/iOS debate. And most people are happier with iOS. (And use Macs over Linux, FWIW.)
[I probably shouldn't mention that I personally think adblockers are unethical :) ]
> And most people are happier with iOS.
Source?
> And use Macs over Linux, FWIW.
This could be explained by marketing.
> I personally think adblockers are unethical
Do you think ads are ethical? For a relevant example, how about an Apple ad that successfully uses emotion to convince you to buy a Mac instead of a Linux computer that would better suit your needs at a better price hypothetically?
> Do you think ads are ethical?
Generally, yes. Ads are an important function of commerce, tbh.
False ads, of course, are not ethical. But we do have laws in that area (not that people don't break them.)
Fair enough! I stand on the side that the current ad landscape in the US gravitates towards convincing us to buy things we don’t need and consume more. And normally using manipulative tactics. For example, ads in the car industry that sell a lifestyle that convinces people to buy large pick up trucks they don’t need at costs they can’t actually afford.
6 replies →
> (And use Macs over Linux, FWIW.)
Interestingly, ChromeOS (Linux) has a higher market share than MacOS.
Being forced to run random code and be tracked is unethical. But I should probably mention I'm a big supporter of the small web.
> [I probably shouldn't mention that I personally think adblockers are unethical :) ]
Okay, I’ll bite. How are adblockers unethical?
Because websites make their money from ads.
There is an implicit agreement that using those websites (for free) means you watch ads. I think: if you don't agree with that, then you shouldn't go to those sites.
We complain about "enshitification" -- but then we take away all potential sources of revenue (and refuse to pay). So the only companies that can provide "free" services are ones that are already monetizing you in other ways.