← Back to context

Comment by ryao

19 days ago

Fluoride in Toothpaste: Do not ingest.

Flouride in Water: Ingest away.

I do not understand how these two can co-exist.

Radioactive isotopes in nuclear fuel: do not ingest.

Radioactive isotopes in banana: consume away.

Understand now? I'm not even defending anything other than how two things that vaguely appear contradictory, are in fact, not.

  • I don’t.

    Because your banana example doesn’t have additives meant to be reactive — so is unlike adding fluoride to water at levels which impact dental health.

    • It's the concentration that matters. Toothpaste has over 1000x the concentration of fluoride vs 0.7mg/L as tap water. Many well water sources have naturally occurring fluoride that exceeds the additive levels.

      6 replies →

    • Maybe another example will help?

      Chlorine for water treatment in the backcountry when applied to a liter of water: Ingest.

      Chlorine straight from a household bleach bottle: Do not ingest.

Fluorine is a dietary mineral.

At higher dosages, every dietary mineral becomes harmful, then (generally) lethal.

Without iron, humans die. Yet accidental (over-)ingestion of iron supplements is a leading cause of poisoning in small children.