← Back to context

Comment by thaumasiotes

1 year ago

I wouldn't find that unusual. I hardly ever drink water; if it's available, I drink milk. Why would you drink water?

If I replaced my water intake with milk it would probably make me sick.

Water has zero calories, is reasonably filling, neutral-tasting, and gives me what my body needs, without any other junk. What's not to like?

  • Well, it's true that water has zero calories and is neutral tasting. It's not filling to any degree, and milk will give you a lot more of what your body needs.

Water is great for hydration without filling you otherwise. Like, say you need to drink a lot of fluid because you are really active, you would probably get sick of milk pretty quickly.

  • > say you need to drink a lot of fluid because you are really active

    If you're replacing sweat, wouldn't you want sports drinks?

    https://www.gocomics.com/peanuts/1969/03/27

    But anyway, in most cases, the fact that drinking milk doubles as a source of food is clearly a benefit. It's hard to explain a common behavior by reference to a rare circumstance.